In the middle of the nineteenth century, the Rio Grande, or Rio Bravo as it is known in Cd. Juárez did what rivers do, meander. The 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo ending the American invasion of México made the river’s deepest channel the boundary. The river didn’t care about treaties and shifted south. After floods in 1864, roughly six hundred acres that once had been in México ended up north of the boundary and the land was absorbed into El Paso. The land was known as El Chamizal, after a desert plant that grew there. By 1900 about 700 acres of former Mexican ground lay on the American side, and Mexican farmers had to cross the river to work their lands.

México was not in the mood to give up more of its land to the U.S., and El Paso wanted the Mexican land for itself. Tired of war, the controversy turned to diplomacy to resolve the standoff. The question before the countries sounded more like a philosophical debate than a diplomatic overture.

Did the river move gradually or suddenly? It made a difference in diplomatic speak.

This was an important distinction because under international law the slow movement of the river shifted international boundaries, but a sudden change of course by the river meant that the boundaries were changed artificially – either by human intervention or by nature.

México argued that the Chamizal (named after the chamizo, a saltbush native to the area) remained Mexican territory, while the United States argued that under the 1884 convention – the gradual change left the land in American hands. An international arbitration in 1911 largely sided with México. However, Washington rejected the ruling, and the matter sat for half a century as an irritant in an otherwise close relationship between the two countries.

Eventually, two presidents broke the stalemate. John F. Kennedy visited Mexico City in 1962 and committed to resolving it with Adolfo López Mateos. Unfortunately, Kennedy was assassinated before the work was finished, but Lyndon Johnson carried the agreement to a treaty that created a binational seat headquartered in El Paso. In 1964 the United States gave back 437 acres of land under the newly minted Chamizal Treaty. The treaty is often held up as a model of peaceful dispute resolution between countries. That praise is deserved, but it obscures how much the settlement was about the lives of ordinary people.

What the Treaty Actually Did

The Chamizal Convention, signed on August 29, 1963, was an engineering project as much as a diplomatic one. It moved the river into a new channel, shifting 823.5 acres of land from the north bank to the south – 366 acres of the Chamizal, 193.16 acres of Córdova Island, and 264.34 more acres on the other side of the island. Córdova Island was a Mexican enclave on the American side of the old riverbed, and the two nations split it equally, with each country keeping 193 acres each. The result was that México gained 437 acres of land. The river itself was confined to a concrete channel of about 4.3 miles, running between El Paso and Ciudad Juárez, and permanently setting the international boundary in concrete.

The Treaty includes several other provisions worth pointing out. These include that both governments will share in the costs to keep the boundary line maintained. It also provided for clean titles to the lands that were transferred, including private lands. The United States compensated owners of 382 buildings in the ceded territory. Many residents moved to other neighborhoods in El Paso and Juárez, others left for different cities and states, and reactions to the forced relocation are mixed. And the clause that affects the City of El Paso’s use of tolls to bolster its finances today.

The Clause That Affects El Paso’s Fee Options

Buried in the treaty is a simple sentence, boring but impactful, nonetheless. The bridges replacing the two old Córdova Island bridges “shall be toll free unless both Governments agree to the contrary,” reads the sentence.

This sentence is why the Bridge of the Americas, or el Puente Libre, remains toll-free today.

The two parts of the sentence sets the prohibition about tolls but leaves a clause to enact them, but only if two federal governments agree to toll border crossers. The sentence makes it impossible for the City of El Paso, the State of Texas, the federal government or their Mexican counterparts from tolling bridge crossers.

Because both the Mexican and U.S. governments would have to agree to toll border crossers, that single sentence has become the most durable sentence in the 63-year-old treaty.

The Bridge of the Americas opened on October 28, 1967, and when the commissioners of the International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) later took up replacing it, they considered using tolls to pay for it. But Article 10 of the Treaty prohibited tolling unless both México and the U.S. agreed.

The IBWC owns the free bridge and maintenance, and construction costs are paid through federal funding from both countries. In 2022, El Paso Congresswoman Veronica Escobar announced that around $600 million in federal funds were allocated to modernize the bridge from the $3.4 billion Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. The modernization contract is expected to be awarded next year with construction expected to be completed in 2031. When completed, commercial traffic through the bridge will be shifted to other international bridges in the region.

Each time using tolls to pay for maintenance or upgrades to the bridge were brought up, the response from the two federal governments was that they would honor the no tolling prohibition clause “in the spirit of the Chamizal Convention.”

El Puente Libre

Residents on both sides of the border call the Bridge of the Americas by a simpler name. Juárez residents call it el Puente Libre, and El Pasoans often use the moniker: the free bridge. It is the only toll-free crossing point between Texas and México in El Paso., It is the crossing point for more than half of the vehicles entering El Paso from Juárez.

For most residents on both sides of the border, the free bridge is a pressure valve for working families. Commuters choose it over the Zaragoza bridge because of the tolls. Tolls tend to strain economically vulnerable communities. For many in the local communities, the toll is not a rounding error, but a tax on them.

Pedestrians pay 50 cents to cross at Zaragosa while vehicles pay around $3.50 to cross the bridge.

The lack of tolls on the Puente Libre has led to rising car and truck traffic and their associated traffic congestion. The Texas RioGrande Legal Aid described the lack of tolls as “a magnet for traffic” leading to environmental concerns in the same communities that the Chamizal Treaty once disrupted as the border was changed.

The Families Versus the Businesses Over Modernization

The Chamizal Treaty, lauded for resolving a centuries-old international dispute is at the center of the latest tension in both communities, families tired of the congestion and pollution versus the business community arguing against removing commercial traffic from the free bridge.

The decision to remove the commercial traffic from the free bridge once the modernization has been completed led the El Paso Chamber of Commerce to urge the federal government to continue to allow commercial traffic, while the Familias Unidas del Chamizal applauded the decision. Affiliated with La Mujer Obrera, the Familias group advocates for families in the Barrio Chamizal neighborhood near the border crossing point.

The Chamizal Treaty promises a free bridge but does clear up if that includes commerce.

Another wrinkle to the debate arrived last week when the El Paso city council voted to allocated almost $73 million to modernize toll collection at the bridges the city owns in El Paso. The bridge tolls are used to bolster the city’s budget, but a free bridge sits awkwardly enticingly border crossers to forgo bolstering El Paso’s finances through tolls.

Two Parks, One Border

The Chamizal also left an often-overlooked legacy – parks on both sides of the international line, built on land that was once contested.

On the American side, the Chamizal National Memorial, established in 1974, is set aside for recreational and cultural use, with music, visual arts, dance, drama, and shared history serving as cultural bridges between the two neighboring cultures. It occupies part of old Córdova Island. The park hosts performing-arts programs and, in a quiet way, serves as a civic argument that the settlement was a success. It is also a monument to people who were moved out of the way. The American portion of Córdova Island today also holds the Bridge of the Americas port of entry and Bowie High School.

On the Mexican side sits its counterpart, Parque Público Federal El Chamizal, and it feels like a different kind of place. A walkway from the El Paso memorial leads across the Bridge of the Americas to the Juárez park, which has an anthropology museum and an amusement park. At the Juárez side can be found picnicking families, children on horses and go-carts, people napping in hammocks, and vendors selling popsicles and aguas frescas. If the El Paso park is a memorial, the Juárez park is a living room for fronterizos. It is large, heavily used, and unmistakably the product of land once controversial.

This is also the logic behind the free bridge. The walk between the two parks is possible, and costs nothing, because the Treaty created both parks and made the crossing between them free by default.

The Chamizal Story

The Chamizal Convention is usually told as a story about two countries resolving a dispute. It is better read as a story about what a treaty can do for people who live on the line it draws. It returned land, moved a river, displaced families, built parks, and, in a single unglamorous sentence, guaranteed that a working-class border community would have one way to cross without paying.

That sentence has outlasted the political moods of six decades. It now faces tests: a federal modernization effort, a city budget that likes tolls, neighbors who want fewer trucks, and a business community that wants more. The easy thing to say is that the free bridge should remain free. The harder thing is to figure out what a free bridge is for. If it is a connector for the families of El Paso and Juárez, it makes sense to design it around them. If it is a free lane for the world’s largest economic bloc, it will eventually collapse under its own generosity.

Cover photograph: President Johnson and Mexican President Gustavo Di­az Ordaz, with their wives, celebrate the dedication of the Chamizal Monument in Juárez, México, on Oct. 28, 1967. Courtesy of the LBJ Presidential Library.

You May Also Like

The Mexican American Women Who Challenged The “White Political Domination” Of El Paso

The women had had enough of the exploitation and abuse behind the façade of a successful El Paso business. Raising their fists, they yelled, “¡Basta!,” enough! taking on the white establishment of El Paso.

The Saving of the Duranguito Barrio, A Movie, and An Inconvenient Truth

The reluctance of local well-to-do Latinos/as to join the Duranguito crusade was deeply disappointing. But even more distressing was the fact that a number of the elite Latinos/as actually supported the plan to raze Duranguito and build the arena there.